Genshin Impact Arlecchino signature weapon vs alternatives

Choosing the right weapon for Arlecchino in Genshin Impact can significantly impact her performance as a Pyro DPS. While her signature weapon, Crimson Moon's Semblance, remains the pinnacle choice, not everyone can afford to pull on the weapon banner. Let's break down how this 5-star polearm compares to other alternatives in 2025, helping you make an informed decision whether you're a whale or completely F2P.

How Crimson Moon's Semblance Performs

Arlecchino's signature weapon boasts an impressive base ATK and CRIT stats that perfectly complement her kit, which revolves around Bond of Life values and normal attacks. The weapon's unique passive synergizes exceptionally well with her playstyle, maximizing her damage potential in various team compositions.

However, the real question is: how do alternatives stack up against it? Is the signature weapon worth the primogems, or can you get by with other options? Let's dive into the best alternatives that have stood the test of time since her release.

Top 5-Star Alternatives

Primordial Jade-Winged Spear

If you're looking for the closest alternative to Crimson Moon's Semblance, look no further than the Primordial Jade-Winged Spear. This weapon matches Arlecchino's signature in base ATK and CRIT stats but differs in its passive effect.

The passive provides substantial ATK% buffs that can jack up Arlecchino's damage output and help reach that sweet 20% All Elemental and Physical RES through her ascension passive. The kicker? You can snag this from the standard banner, making it surprisingly accessible for patient players.

As one player put it: "This spear is the real MVP when you can't shell out for the signature weapon. It's clutch in almost every situation."

Staff of Scarlet Sands

For those running vaporize or melt teams, Staff of Scarlet Sands is giving Arlecchino's signature a run for its money in 2025. While it has lower base ATK, its high CRIT stats help achieve that golden 1:2 CRIT ratio that DPS characters crave.

In reaction-based teams, this weapon sometimes outperforms the Primordial Jade-Winged Spear, making it a solid contender for your Arlecchino build if you happen to have it in your inventory.

Staff of Homa

Still a powerhouse years after its introduction, Staff of Homa continues to be one of the most versatile 5-star polearms in Genshin Impact Arlecchino signature weapon vs alternatives discussions. With decent base ATK and high CRIT DMG stats, it allows you to stack massive amounts of CRIT DMG on Arlecchino.

The weapon's HP-scaling passive not only increases her survivability but also converts that HP into valuable ATK%, creating a win-win situation that's hard to beat.

4-Star Options That Won't Break the Bank

Deathmatch

For Battle Pass purchasers, Deathmatch remains the premier 4-star option for Arlecchino in 2025. Its decent base ATK and CRIT Rate substat make building a balanced CRIT ratio much easier, especially if your artifact luck is in the gutter.

The passive provides both ATK% and DEF% buffs, giving you more damage and tankiness. It particularly shines in single-target scenarios, which is where Arlecchino often wants to be anyway.

Ballad of the Fjords

Another Battle Pass weapon, Ballad of the Fjords, offers similar base stats to Deathmatch but with a different passive that grants 120 Elemental Mastery. This makes it particularly effective for vaporize team compositions, sometimes matching Deathmatch's performance when its effect is active.

Dragon's Bane

Don't sleep on Dragon's Bane if you're running reaction-based teams. Despite its low base ATK, the high Elemental Mastery substat combined with its passive (which increases damage against enemies affected by Pyro or Hydro) makes it a dark horse contender in vaporize and melt teams.

The True F2P MVP: White Tassel

In a classic case of "don't judge a book by its cover," the 3-star White Tassel has proven itself to be an absolute beast for F2P Arlecchino mains. This chest-only weapon features low base ATK but compensates with a CRIT Rate substat and a passive that directly buffs normal attack damage—perfectly aligned with Arlecchino's kit.

At higher refinements (which are easy to achieve since it's a 3-star), White Tassel can outperform many 4-star alternatives, making it the go-to option if you haven't spent a dime on the game.

As one F2P player commented: "I was skeptical about using a 3-star weapon on a 5-star character, but White Tassel on Arlecchino is no joke. It's the real deal when you're saving those primos."

Conclusion: Is Crimson Moon's Semblance Worth It?

When comparing Genshin Impact Arlecchino signature weapon vs alternatives, the signature weapon certainly provides the highest damage ceiling. However, the gap between it and top alternatives like Primordial Jade-Winged Spear or even a well-refined White Tassel isn't as dramatic as you might expect.

If you're a F2P player with limited resources, you're better off saving your primogems for future characters rather than gambling on the weapon banner. The alternatives discussed here will serve you well enough to clear all content in the game.

For dolphins and whales who already have Arlecchino and want to maximize her potential, Crimson Moon's Semblance is certainly the way to go—but don't feel pressured if you're on the fence. Sometimes, the smart play is knowing when to hold your primogems.

What's your experience with Arlecchino's weapon options? Drop a comment below and join the discussion!